The simple rhetoric of the Wisconsin budget battle is that the Democrats are just "thug" unions—and that Republicans are carrying water for wealthy corporate sleaze. It's more complicated than that. For one, several teachers' unions endorsed Wisconsin Republicans last year—unions are hardly the unthinking automatons of the left they're now depicted to be. Why would they do that? Quite simply, those Republicans looked into the face of their constituents… and lied.
As the marquee battle over unions and Walker's bill is happening in Madison, the true fight over changes to the state is happening elsewhere. The ransacking of Wisconsin cannot be done from Madison alone. Governor Scott Walker has furnished the tools, but who will wield them? We've sketched a blueprint of how state Republicans lied to their constituents and conspired with D.C.-based wealth-funded conservative think tanks to not only assemble the "tools" needed to dismantle progressive and middle class power in Wisconsin but also how those organizations trained "mechanics" to use those tools to get "free market conservatives" elected to local offices like city councils and school boards—so that then they can begin to dismantle them.
It all starts in Sauk county.
Walker's budget targets education for the biggest cuts. The bill takes $900 million from K-12 education (about 9 percent of the budget). A property tax cap prevents districts from making up the money. The bill also cuts hundreds of millions from higher education, targeting everything from the University of Wisconsin system to technical education. It is the most drastic cut to education in Wisconsin history.
And those who support Walker's bill have noted that the state elected Republicans in 2010—so the current bill should have been expected and everyone should stop whining.
Sauk county, northwest of Madison, is a microcosm of the state as a whole. Farmers, progressives and social conservatives all mingle. While Dane county went for the Democrats in the 2010 governor's race by more than 20 points, Walker won Sauk by single digits. (As well, Senator Russ Feingold won, also by single digits.)
While it's true that the state elected a Republican majority, candidates were specifically asked about union concessions during their campaigns.
"He lied to us," said teacher Jenny Fish, as she shivered in the 20-degree chill with 100 other protesters outside Reedsburg's Voyageur Inn. Inside was the Sauk County Republican Party Lincoln Day dinner, held after its morning annual caucus and afternoon celebration of Ronald Reagan's 100th birthday. ("Holding the line against Madison.") Fish was in charge of vetting Representative Ed Brooks (R-50) last year for Three Rivers United Educators. His answers were in part what led the union to endorse him, a Republican, for election.
Three Rivers United Educators not only endorsed Brooks, it make a donation to his campaign. Brooks also took money from the Southwest Education Association and the Wisconsin Education Association Council, which is the state's largest teachers union.
Only 3 of the 25 Wisconsin candidates that WEAC endorsed in the 2010 election were Republicans: Richard Spanbauer (R-53), Ed Brooks (R-50) and Dale Schultz, the Sauk county Senator who has been rumored to be breaking with his party. All three won.
Fish said that she asked Brooks if he supported removing collective bargaining for benefits. He said he did not. That answer directly led to his endorsement by the labor union.
Stephanie Hasler, a French teacher at Reedsburg High School, told me that she and a number of Reedsburg teachers visited Brooks in his office on February 18th of this year. At that meeting, Brooks admitted to not having read the budget bill—and he also insisted that the collective bargaining provisions were not in it.
After the bill was unveiled, including the union-busting provisions, Fish said she contacted Brooks. "He basically said he was helpless and could't risk breaking with his party," she said. "He told us, 'Why should I vote no for a bill that's just going to pass anyway?'"
On March 7th, Brooks sent out an email to constituents, defending himself by pointing out "my daughter is a teacher" and claiming that he actually made changes to the bill during a Joint Committee on Finance executive session, including inserting the language that "just cause is still required for termination." Brooks said that changes like this made him "able to vote for Governor Walker's budget repair bill." His email threw some salt on the wound for good measure. He added: "And please note that unions still exist."
(Over two days, I reached out, numerous times, to Rep. Brooks for comment. His office repeatedly said he would call back. He never did.)
This double-cross is what compelled Reedsburg residents to protest for three consecutive days over the weekend.
Stephanie Hasler told me that an impromptu demonstration sprang up on Main Street after negotiations with the Reedsburg school board crumbled. Counting on the new bill measures, the board refused the teachers' offer of a pay freeze and agreement to the Board's offer on retirement insurance from the previous contract negotiations, as well as paying the percentages of insurance and pension that the governor wants. Fearing what the Walker bill would allow the board to do, Hasler, along with a dozen other teachers in the district, chose an unplanned early retirement earlier in the week, so as to save their insurance benefits under the existing contract.
Reedsburg is a town of fewer than 10,000 people. And with all due respect to the thousands gathered in Madison, openly protesting in a small town, where everyone knows everyone, takes incredible guts. Generally, small-town Wisconsinites are much more comfortable grumbling under their breath about things until they die.
The Voyageur, a wonderful relic from the 1960s, is best known for its collection of hundreds of Normal Rockwell magazine covers, ads and portraits. Attendees of the Republican dinner walked by four of Rockwell's 1940s covers for The Grade Teacher, the "Professional Magazine for Classroom Teachers of all Grades." The special guest was U.S. Senator Ron Johnson.
In the Voyageur parking lot, Brooks' arrival was met by a chant of "Recall! Recall! Recall!."
Not in attendance: Dale Schultz, the moderate Republican Senator for Reedsburg who has still not confirmed how he will vote on the bill. As far as Wisconsin can tell, he has become a ghost.
* * *
Joe Hasler, Stephanie's husband, a longtime state Republican, told me he is "appalled by the party's recent hard turn to the right." Joe isn't just your everyday Republican. Joe was Tommy Thompson's campaign treasurer—Thompson, who was praised and evoked in Walker's budget address.
One of the reasons moderate Wisconsin Republicans have seen the party slide from their grasp is a massive influx of out-of-state money from groups such as the Koch-founded Americans for Prosperity and the Sam Adams Alliance.
Sauk county contains a perfect example of exactly how the corporate takeover on the state level will be implemented on the local level.
Walker's fundamental change to the education system in Wisconsin via funding cuts, tax caps and charter promotion is not that damaging without local level implementation. As Walker has said, his bill is a "tool." Tools need mechanics.
So, in Reedsburg, city officials have floated a solution. They want to move the town's fire protection charge from tax rolls to utility bills. That frees up around $200,000. For Walker's plans to be truly effective, there must be those at the local level, like in Reedsburg, who are willing to look people they've known all their life in the eyes… and fire them.
Enter the American Majority.
On Saturday, at about the exact moment Michael Moore was addressing 40,000 people at the Capitol (and comparing events in Madison to those in Egypt), about four-and-a-half miles away at the Vitense driving range and minigolf course, the American Majority was holding a sold-out day-long training event. The event, in partnership with the Sauk County Tea Party, consisted of lessons like "Implementing Freedom" which teaches "how to plan a campaign, fine tune your communication skills, and fundraise." The event provided "an opportunity to meet other patriots in your community, the seminar provides an opportunity to network and learn from grassroots organizers with successful campaign experience."
Now, is that "community organizing?" Because it uses the both those words and sure as hell sounds like community organizing.
American Majority brags that it trained 27 city council candidates in Oklahoma and saw 17 of them win. More importantly, the group claims that all but one of those 17 had never run for office before.
In an interview with WisPolitics, a co-founder of the Virginia-based organization, Drew Ryun said, "The letter behind that candidates’ name to some extent does not matter… What matters is are these folks at any level of government that are advancing free market conservative principals."
(A note: When some political organization or think tank is identified in the press as "Virginia-based," that means it's in "Washington D.C.")
But despite that claim, American Majority does not actually support Democrats. Currently the organization's website features a large "Stand with Walker" banner, coincidentally the same motto used by the heavily funded ad campaign from Koch's Americans for Prosperity.
American Majority does partner with such "nonpartisan" groups as Franklin Center's new venture "Wisconsin Reporter," which is a PR interest disguised as journalism to seed information—such as the recent poll that claimed 71% of Wisconsinites favor Walker's budget changes. (See, it's got "reporter" right there in the name.) The Franklin Center, in turn, is associated with groups such as the Sam Adams Alliance—an outfit that I ran into on Capitol Square a week ago. One of their "grassroots" surveyors was soliciting people in Starbucks for 20 minutes of their time, for which they would be paid $10.
Not clear enough? Scott Walker refers to his budget bill as a "tool." American Majority refers to its local activists as "mechanics."
American Majority was founded by Ned and Drew Ryun, sons of longtime Kansas Republican Representative Jim Ryun. (Yes, Kansas, home of the Kochs.) Jim Ryun's federal campaign finance report reads like a list of tens of thousands of dollars from the Kochs, going all the way back to 1997.
American Majority was organized by, and receives a great deal of its funding through, the Chicago-based Sam Adams Alliance, which carefully protects the list of its patrons and has gone to pains (though not effectively enough) to remove evidence that it is in large part funded by the Kochs. American Majority is also partnered with Koch organizations that don't hide the Koch connection at all, like Americans for Prosperity.
Sam Adams Alliance is very much funded by the Kochs—but even if they were not, Eric O'Keefe, the chairman and CEO of the Sam Adams Alliance, is also a board member at the Institute for Humane Studies, a group which has received millions from the Kochs and for which Charles Koch is the chairman. O'Keefe is also a board member at the Wisconsin Club for Growth, a state office of the organization funded by the wealthiest of Americans. The Club has become one of the most influential organizations in Wisconsin politics. (The CFG supported Ron Johnson over Russ Feingold and its to-date $320,000 in spending for the 2011 campaign of conservative State Supreme Court Justice David Prosser accounts for about 70 percent of total TV ad expenditures in that election).
And Eric O'Keefe lives in Spring Green, Sauk County.
* * *
American Majority chose the term "mechanics" because this was the name of the first intelligence network put together by independence-minded colonists. The group, whose most famous member was Paul Revere, gathered information on the British and conducted minor sabotage. Explaining the name, American Majority's pull quote begins "In the days before the Revolutionary War, Paul Revere organized the Mechanics, a group of determined patriots that grew out of the Sons of Liberty." The unattributed copy is lifted from Revolutionary-war-and-beyond.com.
As the CIA history of the period's intelligence notes of the "mechanics": "Their security practices, however, were amateurish. They met in the same place regularly (the Green Dragon Tavern), and one of their leaders (Dr. Benjamin Church) was a British agent."
The questionnaire that American Majority uses to identify those who will, according to co-founder Ned Ryun, "organize their communities, hard-wire their precincts, learn how to become effective online, and to understand the system that we are confronting," gives a hint of what the group is trying to weed out. The questionnaire, below:
American Majority Mechanics Eligibility Questionnaire
1. What do you believe the role of government should be in America?2. Do you have any experience with public speaking and presenting?
3. How do you feel about the “Birther” issue?
4. Please list any and all current organizations you are presently associated
with.5. What do you hope to get out of becoming an authorized American Majority Mechanic?
6. What terms do you best believe describe our government and leadership
today?7. How well do you know the Constitution and Declaration of Independence?
8. What do you believe are the most important political issues this country is facing right now?
9. Who is your political hero and why?
10. Please list all websites, social networks, and blogs in which you have a presence.
11. How comfortable are you with public speaking and presenting on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 10 being very comfortable)?
12. How comfortable are you with technology on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 10 being very comfortable)?
13. How comfortable are you with social networks, including Facbook, Twitter, and YouTube on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 10 being very comfortable)?
14. Please list at least two professional references and their contact information so that we can talk with your peers.
The mechanics program is a bit like a franchise. American Majority "mechanics will receive 75% of the net from their trainings" and the 2010 program required mechanics to perform at least one training per month, for a minimum of 30 trainees through the end of 2010. At $20 per person, that's a minimum take for the mechanic of $450 per month. I attempted to attend the $20 per head training in Madison on March 5th but it was booked solid.
The mechanics program was put together and began recruiting in February, 2010. Formal training took place March 24th to 26th, with American Majority flying recruits to Washington D.C., covering all travel and board. And then the Sauk County Tea Party was founded on June 17, 2010.
Later in 2010, the Sauk County Tea Party began linking to and endorsing strategy meetings with American Majority. In mid-December of 2010, the group took part in a strategy call with co-founder Ned Ryun to discuss the New Leaders Project.
On December 29th, Sauk Tea Party President John Meegan announced his candidacy for Baraboo school board.
Meegan's ties to O'Keefe's American Majority go beyond the training seminars. Just a few weeks ago, Meegan organized area counter-protesters to go to Madison, in the process telling the Baraboo News Republic that he was "working with a national group called American Majority." The News Republic piece interviewed another counter-protester, Lori Mislivecek, noting she was a "Baraboo resident." What it did not note was that she is also listed as one of 37 members of the Sauk County Tea Party. In anticipation of the trip to Madison, Meegan sent an email insisting "all signage should be supportive of the budget reform bill, Gov. Walker, conservative legislators, freedom, liberty, rule of law, etc. No partisan or violent signage allowed."
Fight Back Wisconsin counts the Sauk County Tea Party as part of its "Prosperity Network." Fight Back Wisconsin and Kochs' Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin's share an address on South 70th Street in Milwaukee.
Asked about financial support for from the Wisconsin office of Americans For Prosperity to "grassroots" tea party groups within its coalition, such as the Sauk County Tea Party, or its ties to American Majority, Matt Seaholm, director of AFP-Wisc., told me there is no such official support "beyond a shared interest."
Except, just after the 2010 election, Americans for Prosperity- Wisconsin announced that the "Wisconsin Prosperity Network" had "helped privatize the Center Right political processes with the development and financial support of Prosperity 101, First Freedom Foundation, The MacIver Institute, American Majority, and Americans for Prosperity."
One more interesting detail about Meegan's school board candidacy is that his one child, a teenage daughter, does not even attend school in Baraboo. His daughter attends IQ Academy, "a complete online middle and high school" based in Waukesha, over 100 miles away, near Milwaukee. IQ Academy benefits from Wisconsin's unique open enrollment policies which redistribute vouchers from the school system (for which parents pay taxes). As advertised on IQ Academy's website, for Wisconsin residents the school is "tuition-free."
An open letter that Meegan wrote to the Baraboo School Board in Jan. 2011, well after working with American Majority and just before Walker's budget introduction, outlines demands curiously similar to what Walker finally addressed, including "removal of all open enrollment limits related to virtual charter schools."
In the February primary, Meegan received more votes than any other candidate. Next up, the April 4 general election.
* * *
So, to review: In 2010, the Club for Growth and the Koch Brothers heavily supported the election of Scott Walker. Union-busting legislation is written for Walker to submit in 2011. Meanwhile, Club for Growth and Koch Brothers trustee Eric O'Keefe's Sam Adams Alliance launches the American Majority New Leaders Project, which, in 2010, partners with the Sauk County Tea Party, to train free market conservatives to run for office. Those candidates include Sauk County Tea Party co-founder John Meegan, who announces in December, 2010 that he is running for a seat on the Baraboo school board.
It's almost a given that the John Meegan-Eric O'Keefe example is but one simple detailed example of something that is no doubt going on in all contested counties across the state… and more. Scheduled American Majority training events in the near future include Waxahachie, TX, Crowley, LA, Outer Banks, NC and Bowling Green, KY.
(Messages requesting comment from Eric O'Keefe, John Meegan and the American Majority were not returned.)
The new conservatives love to use the home budget metaphor when debating government spending. They argue that the government should have to watch its spending just like ordinary folk. Tea Party Review Magazine just published an argument from National Taxpayers Union's Jordan Forbes: "Families balance their budgets' Politicians must do the same." In it, Forbes asks: "Why can’t Congress make a budget and stick to it? That’s something that most families across this country do all the time, year in and year out. It’s not easy, especially in hard times…."
Why does this favored metaphor disintegrate when it comes to targeting cuts to balance that budget? When "most families across this country" are faced with making spending cuts, the one cut they make last of all is to their children's future. But that's exactly what Scott Walker and Wisconsin Republicans are doing. In an attempt to balance the family budget, the governor is looking first at what he can cut from the children's schooling, so that he can keep the premium cable channels.
Correction: This piece originally noted that the "New Leaders Project trained 27 city council candidates in Oklahoma and saw 17 of them win." AM launched the "New Leaders Project" at the end of 2010 for the 2011/2012 election cycle. Those successes in OK were achieved through an unnamed program.
Abe Sauer can be reached at abesauer at gmail dot com.
Over the weekend, a minor firestorm erupted over a new feature in the official Twitter iPhone and iPad clients known as the “Quick Bar,” a strip at the top of a user’s tweet-stream designed to show trending topics. As users started criticizing the feature for being too intrusive, however, it quickly became known as the “dickbar,” in reference to Twitter CEO Dick Costolo. Although the company has since said that a new update is on its way that will make the feature less annoying, the outrage over the #dickbar is a symptom of a larger problem for Twitter: it wants to be a business, and users have gotten used to it being a utility.
The update with the Quick Bar included was actually released on Thursday, and the trending topics feature was just one of a number of enhancements that Twitter introduced in that update, including automated URL shortening (using the company’s internal shortener, t.co, which it launched last year) and an auto-complete function for user names and hashtags — including, ironically, the #dickbar hashtag. Criticism of the Quick Bar seemed to pick up speed, and then exploded over the weekend.
One of the big complaints about the new feature is the way the trending topics bar gets overlaid on top of the Twitter stream, appearing whenever the feed was refreshed, and partially obscuring tweets. According to spokesman Sean Garrett, the new update that Twitter has submitted to the Apple store “fixes some bugs, and makes it so the quickbar doesn’t overlay on tweets” — but judging by his tweets and those from CEO Costolo, there’s no sign the company plans to allow users to disable or turn off the feature, something many have been asking for since it was introduced.
Although a number of users have said that they find the whole idea of trending topics irritating and unnecessary, Costolo has made it clear that this is a key part of the service’s functionality, saying “If users didn’t like trends, we wouldn’t have trends.” And while the Twitter CEO didn’t come right out and say so, one of the obvious reasons is that promoted tweets and promoted trends are two of the ways in which the company is trying to generate revenue and profits — and doing this has become even more important now that Twitter is theoretically valued somewhere between $3.7 billion (based on its last round of financing) and $7.7 billion as a result of secondary-market trading.
The Quick Bar fiasco may be a minor event, but it is an indication of a larger problem for Twitter: namely, that it has spent so much of its life being an open communications platform — more like a social-networking utility than a business, with a focus on how it can enable real-time publishing for everyone, including those fighting oppressive governments around the world — that it is jarring for users whenever the company does something cold or calculating like suddenly cutting off Twitter applications (as it did recently with Ubermedia) or implementing features that are clearly designed more to generate revenue than they are to serve the needs of users.
This is a line that Facebook has been trying to walk as well, of course — being a social utility, but also making money from advertising — but it seems to have done a better job of mixing the two so far. As Costolo tries to expand the business to justify those soaring valuations, we are likely to see more clashes with users rather than less.
Related GigaOM Pro content (sub req’d):
- As Twitter Develops, Developers Quiver in Fear
- Lessons From Twitter: How to Play Nice With Ecosystem Partners
- How Human Users Are Holding Twitter Back
Surface Encounters proudly ensures customer satisfaction and price tag setting up granite assurance. “I’m at all times skeptical going with new providers, but your staff has built me a believer!” - Steve, Indianapolis
Surface Encounters is actually a fast-growing surface encounters business and, however they have kept tempo with every one of the recent client referrals. “This provider is amongst the most budget friendly, trusted and friendly organizations while in the overall state. I'd suggest them to everybody.” - Mike R., South Bend
Plenty of effort goes into developing wonderful countertops from nature. The process contains laser measurement artistic vein matching, precision diamond and water-jet cutting, edging and qualified set up. An individual cannot plainly get in touch with in their buy for the custom countertop and have it inside of per day or two. Good quality normally requires time.
Surface Encounters encourages men and women to visit a showroom to realize extra about natural stone countertops. Aside from the choice and fabrication system, an additional fundamental component of buyer care is making sure one is aware of the best way to treatment for their granite countertop to maintain it hunting new for many years to arrive.
Granite is often a beautiful natural stone merchandise which is a well-known substance employed for countertops and floor tiles in kitchens and bathrooms. Granite has surpassed marble in attractiveness as a result of is it even more tough and simpler to care for. Granite is unmatched by synthetic products and solutions for its strength and sturdiness, tolerance to temperature improvements and resistance to stains and scratches.
Granite is known as a by natural means formed stone that is certainly quarried from deep from the earth, harvested, lower, polished, sealed and set up in houses to add splendor, elegance and design. As a result of it is a natural product or service, no two slabs are exactly alike. Granite is offered in a number of colors from the several minerals that are uncovered within the rock. Considering it arrives from all over the world, different regions and environmental things ensure it is completely unique.
Granite is primarily developed up of quartz crystal, however it also features varied amounts of other metals which include feldspar, mica, copper and iron. Some granite could have bits of gold or silver. The quantity of every single metal is dependent on the region it arrives from. All granite is shaped into a really hard stone by warmth and pressure. Rain adds other minerals because it is forming. It will be readily available throughout the planet, in every last region, and just about every area will make a surface encounters distinctive number of granite.
Surface Encounters state-of-the-art machinery makes certain the highest high quality finished product or service as they design and style and produce some of the greatest kitchens and bathrooms. Granite Countertops improve the warmth and beauty of homes though growing their worth and improving lifestyles.
Surface Encounters can be concerned with employee morale; joyful personnel are much more probably to contribute for the victory of a business enterprise. Also to becoming a productive organization and 1 which is fantastic to get the job done for, Surface Encounters does their portion to preserve our planet.
Surface Encounters does what is best suited for their users, workers and the environment. Surface Encounters utilizes superior h2o recycling capabilities to recycle up to 43,000 gallons of water on a daily basis. On top of that, 100 % for the scrap created in establishing elegant kitchens and lovely baths is re-used as aggregate in road building up, surface preparations and concrete.
The Columbus, Ohio Grand Opening of Surface Encounters features an artwork gallery showroom of Granite, Marble, Quartz and Engineered Stone counter tops. Save Manager, Scott Donnelly unlocked the doorways in the showroom at 4717 Roberts Street, just west with the I-270 Beltway. The Surface Encounters manufacturing procedure uses precision, automated technological know-how all through the fabrication on the customer's custom-made counter prime, these as: a laser measuring alignment that programs the diamond-tipped sculpturing blades. Surface Encounters' practice includes computer-driven application that perpetuates the stone's pure veins. Each individual Surface Encounter keep has a minimum of 1 registered, interior designer to help you in producing the completed project you are trying for. The craftsmanship continues with the
Property owners are deciding to remodel rather than promote their properties in today’s market
Granite countertops have become a the best preference amongst Wixom people for kitchen remodeling jobs. Kitchen remodeling is usually the first undertaking tackled with families paying 3,000 hours or even more per year within their kitchen. Granite countertops furnish an environment that enhances the high-quality time put in with relatives and acquaintances. Granite countertops final a lifetime and increase the excellent of houses.
Surface Encounters Wixom retail outlet manager, Sal Dellacasa, says there are numerous factors shoppers are choosing granite for their countertop wants. “Granite countertops add beauty and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is obtainable in the number of vibrant colours and prosperous textures and its strength and sturdiness is unmatched by any other healthy stone or synthetic countertop content.”
Surface Encounters’ customers relish certified service and a friendly, effective workers to guide them with the kitchen remodeling method. A lot of of Surface Encounters new clients are referred to them by preceding people.
"This company is amongst the most cost effective, trusted, and pleasant companies during the total state. I would endorse them to any individual." Mike R. Clinton Twp., MI
"The corporation has often been there to help me in no matter what way possible. Thank you so much!" David V. Lapeer, MI
Surface Encounters Macomb is the residential home of half-off granite for kitchen and bathroom countertops. Granite countertops by Surface Encounters have speedily turn out to be the the best decision for Macomb residents that are remodeling their kitchens. Kitchen remodeling normally requires priority with families spending three,000 hrs or even more per year in their kitchen. Granite countertops deliver an setting that enhances the quality time spent with family and colleagues and better the good quality of real estate.
Surface Encounters Macomb retail outlet manager, Sal Dellacasa, says there are lots of motives customers are opting for granite for his or her countertop needs. “Granite countertops add splendor and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is available inside a variety of vibrant shades and loaded textures and its strength and sturdiness is unmatched by every other surface encounters normal stone or artificial countertop content.”
Surface Encounters’ clients enjoy specialist services and also a pleasant, helpful staff to guide them with the kitchen remodeling procedure. A lot of of Surface Encounters new consumers are referred to them by prior customers.
